This following is a re-post of a review I had done on the first series (in 2020) after being shown it while visiting out-of-town friends. (See it in The Coffee Shop here on PB, May 2021 - I can't link to it)
_______
Thoughts on film series, The Chosen
1.
Personal Experience
I was introduced to
The Chosen (TC) recently. I watched the whole series of the first season’s eight films, plus the Xmas special. I was intrigued as it is a very powerful presentation, and deeply moving emotionally in places — particularly when “Jesus” interacts with certain individuals, and yet on the face of it is clearly in violation of Scripture. I wondered about those emotionally moving parts which touched me deeply on occasion. I think it was from a sort of inadvertent “willing suspension of disbelief” <
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suspension_of_disbelief> mixed with a familiar Character (who has my heart in His heart), my own vital faith, and a plausible and winsome actor in that role.
And, as I see it, all the more dangerous for its being so well done. Yes, TC does bring to our minds the truth that there is much more to the humanity and the relationships of Jesus than we see in the Scriptures, and so we give these scenes credence, and take them in as though, at least,
possible, and for some folks, as good as real. Admittedly, Jonathan Roumie is a very good actor (his background is Roman Catholic). The danger is the
diminishing of the glory of God, and of His Christ, as I examine below.
There are things we shall not know about Jesus and His relationships until we see Him in glory, and we must be satisfied with not knowing, satisfied with what the Scriptures reveal. What we should indeed strive to know is a deeper apprehension of His presence, by means of the word of God and the Holy Spirit revealing Him to us. Such is one of my burdens for the church, as in the piece linked to below, “God’s Presence Our Portion”.
Those who come from involvement in the Charismatic community may be especially open to this, being vulnerable to emotion and feeling displacing spiritual reality. As Jesus said,
“It is the spirit that quickens; the flesh profits nothing: the words that I speak unto you, they are spirit, and they are life” (John 6:63)
; “That which is born of the flesh is flesh; and that which is born of the Spirit is spirit” (John 3:6). The flesh produces that which is delusional, especially in the realm of that which is supposedly spiritual. The films are almost addictive in their power – I am quite aware of their power, even over my own heart! I do not think I will be following the series next year – they are dangerous to my spirit. After watching the first season (in two sittings), my mind is polluted with fictitious and fleshly / worldly images – recently in the case of Nicodemus, as I’m reading in John 3 presently.* When Scripture is silent, we should be silent.
* (The Lord will enable me to remove the pollution and power of the images. They are lies, which intrude on and corrupt the actual truths of the divine record.)
2.
Biblical Scrutiny
“Certainly,” remarks Calvin (
A Harmony of the Gospels, Mt. 26:37), “those who imagine that the Son of God was exempt from human passions [feelings], do not truly and seriously acknowledge him to be a man.” At the same time we know that the Lord Jesus had two distinct natures in His Person, the divine – His full deity as God the eternal Son – and the human, fully taking on human nature as a true man in the womb of His mother, Mary.
We also know that not all the “feelings” Jesus had were restricted to His human nature, as His Father “so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son” (John 3:16) for the redemption of humankind through His sacrifice, and Jesus’ heart was one with His Father’s in this loving mission of redeeming the human race. Jesus loved and cherished those elected of God even before He took on our nature (Eph 1:4; Rev 13:8). Yet Jesus also loved men and women with the human emotions He had as a man. A good study of this matter is the classic essay by Benjamin B. Warfield, “The Emotional Life of Our Lord” (
https://bit.ly/3o9RuOD).
In the film series,
The Chosen, Jesus is winsomely portrayed as, at times, “a regular guy”, winking, joking, and laughing with His friends, among them His disciples who were to become the apostles we read of in the Scriptures. This depiction of His character is not warranted by the word of God, by which only we know anything of Jesus.
This is not to say He had no sense of humor, a human quality, yet it is not shown in the record of His life, so we may not attribute it to Him through fictional instances conjured by
mere human imagination. What we are shown in
The Chosen is mere human humor and is the forbidden, “Ye shall not add unto the word which I command you, neither shall ye diminish ought from it, that ye may keep the commandments of the LORD your God which I command you” (Deut 4:2). In a number of places we are commanded neither to add nor to diminish even a word from what God has spoken to us in the Bible (Prov 30:6; Jer 26:2; Rev 22:18, 19) – the Bible alone is the word of God.
We should also remember, the controlling “I” in the Person of Jesus Christ – although He possessed a human nature – was that of God the eternal Son. His human nature never had its own separate personality.
But in
The Chosen are numerous instances of the Bible, and the Gospel, being added to, through made-up conversations and activities of Jesus and other Biblical persons, coming merely from 21st century fiction writers. So what we see and hear are
falsehoods. Well-meant, no doubt, but untrue, and dangerously perverting –
distorting – the Biblical picture of our Lord. Presuming to put words in the Lord’s mouth – whether in a film or a book – is the sin of adding to the record of His words.
Even more serious, if such can be, are the portrayals of Jesus. In Scripture – and in reality, for the Bible alone shows what is real as regards God, and His Christ – we do not see Jesus joking around as the film shows. Yes, He had emotions, but not as the actor displays. For the consciousness of Jesus Christ had as its foundation,
its base, these desires,
attitudes, of His deity:
“For this purpose the Son of God was manifested, that he might destroy the works of the devil” (1 John 3:8).
All His life, especially after His 40 days in the wilderness fasting in preparation for His ministry, He was about binding the devil and destroying his works, namely the oppression of men and women through illness, demonic possession, and sin, and setting men free from the power of darkness and translating them into the kingdom of God. Every leper or blind healed, every demon cast out, every sinner converted, were mighty blows against the demonic realm, and the tearing down of its kingdom. This was always in His consciousness.
He was always alert to the presence of both His enemies among men, and those who were His, given Him by the Father:
“But ye believe not, because ye are not of my sheep, as I said unto you. My sheep hear my voice, and I know them, and they follow me” (John 10:26, 27)
Even though He was a Man of sorrows (Isa 53:3), empathizing with our suffering, yet on a deeper level he was a Man of joy, for “thy God, hath anointed thee with the oil of gladness above thy fellows” (Heb 1:9)
“Joy he had: but it was not the shallow joy of mere pagan delight in living . . . but the deep exultation of a conqueror setting captives free.” (Warfield, “The Emotional Life…”.
The Person and Work of Christ, p 126)
[Christ] “is the Man of Sorrows, yet we cannot think of him for a moment as an unhappy man. He rather gives us the picture of serene and unclouded happiness. Beneath not merely the outward suffering, but the profound sorrow of heart, there is deeper still a continual joy, derived from the realized presence of his Father and the consciousness that he is doing his work.” (Ibid., Cited in Warfield; F. W. Farrar,
The Life of Christ, 1874, i. p. 318; ii. p. 103)
Jesus of Nazareth was a warrior King come from Heaven into the world ravaged by the demonic powers, to save sinners, the broken hearted, the hopeless, and to give them saving faith, hope, and love so as to become new creatures indwelt by the Holy Spirit and adopted into the royal family of the living God. He was always alert and conscious, both in His deity, and in His human nature, of where He was, who He was, and among whom He was. He was not severed in His human nature from the consciousness of His divine nature, to be joking around as a mere man – a “regular guy” – as the movie seeks to convey. He was the eternal God come to take on our nature so as to be a fit Mediator and High Priest before God for us, and then to bring us into union with Him, body and soul, to be partakers in Him of the glory of God.
There was an infinite dignity and majesty about Him, calm and filled with power to proclaim the Gospel of the kingdom with authority – the authority of the triune God – and devils trembled when they saw Him. Jesus may well have laughed when He was with children, or seeing the joy in a holy wedding, but we have no record of that, and we shall be satisfied to know He was fully man as well as God, and wait till we see Him face-to-face to learn more of His life, both while on earth and in glory. To depict Him behaving as the film does – in the likeness of a mere fallen, but nice, man – is to diminish His glory, the infinite majesty and gentleness of His Person.
What can never be conveyed in a film is, similar to many other encounters the Lord had with men and women, the incident at the pool of Bethesda (John 5:1-9) where Jesus said to the impotent man who couldn’t get down to the pool for healing, “Rise, take up thy bed, and walk” and as he looked into Jesus’ face (2 Cor 4:6; John 1:14) became aware of the divine glory and power of God flowing through Him and into his own being, giving him the energy and health to indeed miraculously rise, take up his bed, and walk, immediately being made whole, having been quickened by the presence and power of God.
Only in the word of God, being read, or heard, does the Spirit of God reveal to us the reality of God’s presence, His infinite majesty, power, and love, which mere human imagery can never convey, “because they are spiritually discerned” (1 Cor 2:14).
_______
I have not previously brought up the 2nd Commandment violation exhibited in the films – a depiction of God by means of an image (the actor playing Jesus Christ) to be worshipped – as many who will read this are not Reformed and won’t relate to this understanding of the commandment. Yet it is true, and I have sought to indicate this in the substance of my remarks above.
_______
Link to the paper, “God’s Presence Our Portion”, on my Google Drive:
https://bit.ly/3fUNYEP