Has anyone read Early Christian Doctrine by J.N.D. Kelly?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Wooster

Wooster

Puritan Board Freshman
Hi everyone,

I saw the book Early Christian Doctrine by J.N.D. Kelly on ChristianBook.com for $7.99 and was wondering if it's worth picking up. I'm not familiar with Kelly.

Thanks for any feedback!

God Bless,
Paul
 
No, but is your username taken from Bertrand Wilberforce Wooster of the P.G. Wodehouse series? :D
 
GPTS required text

I will be reading it for a class this Fall semester as it is a required text for Greenville Presbyterian Theological Seminary - if that is any indication of its value for you. :2cents:
 
This book was also assigned for one my my classes. I purchased it when I saw I would have to read it. Then the class got a new professor assigned to teach it and he changed all the readings. So, I haven't read it yet. But I presume it is a good book if it was assigned by one of my professors. :)
 
Davidius said:
No, but is your username taken from Bertrand Wilberforce Wooster of the P.G. Wodehouse series? :D
Click to expand...
Absolutely! :D I love those stories. There are some great audio dramatizations floating around of them too.

CaseyBessette said:
But I presume it is a good book if it was assigned by one of my professors.
Click to expand...
mangum said:
I will be reading it for a class this Fall semester as it is a required text for Greenville Presbyterian Theological Seminary
Click to expand...
Thanks guys, that's very helpful. I'm going to pick it up.

God Bless,
Paul
 
Wooster said:
Davidius said:
No, but is your username taken from Bertrand Wilberforce Wooster of the P.G. Wodehouse series? :D
Click to expand...
Absolutely! :D I love those stories. There are some great audio dramatizations floating around of them too.
Click to expand...

Awesome! That's the best series in the world. My wife and I have all four series on DVD and really want to read some of the books. What are the audio dramatizations you mention?
 
I would highly recommend Kelly's ealry Christian doctrines. I have used this is a lot particularly in debates with JWs. Books always seem much cheaper in the US so $7.99 seems like a good price from this end of the pond.
 
The book is well done; it was also required reading at WSCAL (at least when I was there).

On the other hand, considering the fact that they allowed me to enroll might make one question anything WSCAL did in those days. And then they allowed me to graduate (mainly to get me out of there)... but I digress.
 
Kelly's book is an excellent rendition of what early Christians believed. From time to time one may disagree with this or that, but generally it is a reliable guide. It was a much needed text given the bizarre historiography that came earlier from Harnack and his school.

Be aware that Kelly himself is an orthodox Anglo-Catholic.
 
I have read Kelly's book. I recommend it to any who are interested in what the "early church" believed. I have two copies in our church library. It is borrowed often.

For $8.00 you can't go wrong!
 
Wooster said:
Hi everyone,

I saw the book Early Christian Doctrine by J.N.D. Kelly on ChristianBook.com for $7.99 and was wondering if it's worth picking up. I'm not familiar with Kelly.
Click to expand...

Kelly has a weak view of Holy Scripture in terms of how he views (for example) the authorship of 2 Peter, but he is an excellent church historian. In addition to his Early Christian Doctrines, I recommend highly his biographies of Jerome and Chrysostom. They exhibit sound scholarship and are simply fascinating to read. Their titles are...

Jerome, His Life, Writings, and Controversies

and

Golden Mouth: The Story of John Chrysostom, Ascetic, Preacher, Bishop.

DTK
 
From a church history perspective (especially as a resource), it is a worthwhile purchase (especially for 8 bucks!). If you can get over the image of Christ on the cover (though I think it's being printed with a different cover now), that is.
-----------
Tim Phillips
Pastor, Midlane Park Presbyterian Church
Louisville, KY
 
Wooster said:
Hi everyone,

I saw the book Early Christian Doctrine by J.N.D. Kelly on ChristianBook.com for $7.99 and was wondering if it's worth picking up. I'm not familiar with Kelly.

Thanks for any feedback!

God Bless,
Paul
Click to expand...

Great book on Partristics, but there are others, too. Don't forget W Cunningham and G Bromiley (Historical Theology)
 
Kelley is a classic. We used it a hundred years ago at Fuller. As has already been mentioned, he will not fit into a PB mold. However, for a patristics guy, he is hard to beat. One of my profs, Geoffrey Bromiley did a fine job in his Historical Theology too. I think I paid more for Kelley back then than what you can get it for now! Grrrrr.

If you want to read up on the controversies of the early church from a Reformed evangelical perspective, Harold O.J. Brown's book Heresies: The Image of Christ in the Mirror of Heresy and Orthodoxy from the Apostles to the Present (1984) is full of good material. With his four degrees from Harvard/Harvard Divinity School, his staunch commitment to the unborn, and his outspoken commitment to the full trustworthiness of Scripture, he is a reliable guide in this area.
 
Wow, thanks for all the fantastic feedback! I thought I may get one or two responses. I ordered the book today. This is a foundational area that honestly, I haven't studied, so I'm looking forward to reading it.

God Bless,
Paul
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top